An older two-storey house with cream walls, a steep grey roof and a brick chimney, with a tidy front garden on a sunny day
Hub - Selling After a Life Change/
Save

Selling a House an Insurer Will Not Cover in BC: Old Wiring, an Old Roof, an Oil Tank

A buyer with a mortgage needs home insurance, so a house an insurer declines can lose its buyer late in the sale. This guide explains what insurers look at, the features of older houses that raise questions, what a seller must disclose, and what to fix or document before listing.

Michael Goering, BC-licensed REALTOR®

Michael Goering·BC-licensed REALTOR®

A long-time owner knows the house has old wiring or a roof near the end of its life, and has lived with it for years. The surprise comes during the sale. The buyer's insurance company asks its questions, and a sale that looked finished stops. This guide explains why the buyer's insurer matters to a seller, what it looks at, and what to do before the house is listed.

It is general information. Each insurer sets its own rules, and a lawyer advises on the contract.

Why does the buyer's insurance decide the sale?

A buyer who borrows has a lender to satisfy. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) says a home insurance policy on a mortgaged home usually includes a loss payee clause, which makes the mortgage lender the beneficiary. If the house is damaged, the insurer pays the lender up to the balance of the mortgage.

That clause ties the three together. A buyer who cannot get a policy cannot give the lender what it asks for, and the purchase cannot complete. The buyer can find this out after the offer is accepted, while the conditions are still open. The seller finds out when the buyer asks for more time, a lower price or a release.

What do insurers look at?

FCAC lists the factors insurance companies may consider when they set a premium:

  • the type of residence, such as a single family home, a semi-detached home or a condo
  • the characteristics of the residence, such as the materials it is made of, its age, size, location and replacement value
  • the distance between the home and a fire hydrant or a fire station
  • the crime rate in the neighbourhood
  • the claims history
  • the type of policy, the coverage and the deductible

Age and materials are on that list, and they are what an older house is questioned about. FCAC also says premiums vary from one insurance company to another, and it tells consumers to compare quotes. For a seller this is useful: another company may give a different answer.

Which parts of an older house raise questions?

In our view these are the ones to check before listing. Each insurer decides for itself, so treat this as a list of questions to expect.

Part of the houseWhat an insurer or buyer may askWhat helps
WiringHow old is it, what type, and has an electrician inspected it?An electrician's written report, permits for any upgrade
RoofHow old is it, and what is it made of?The invoice from the last replacement, a roofer's report
PlumbingWhat are the pipes made of, and have they leaked?Invoices for replaced sections
HeatingIs it oil, wood or an old furnace?Service records, the installer's permit
Oil tankIs there one in the ground or the basement?A scan report, or the removal report and soil results
Past water or fire damageWhat happened, and how was it repaired?The repair records and any claim papers

Three of our posts for buyers explain what they are told to check: knob and tube and aluminum wiring, asbestos in older homes and oil furnace conversions. Our guides to a buried oil tank and to fire, flood and mold damage cover those two from the seller's side.

What must a seller disclose?

BC Financial Services Authority (BCFSA) regulates real estate agents. It says sellers have a duty to disclose latent defects, and it defines a material latent defect as a defect that cannot be discerned through a reasonable inspection of the property, including one that makes the property dangerous or potentially dangerous to the occupants.

Two of its statements apply to older houses:

  • new installations or renovations of electrical or gas systems completed without appropriate permits and inspections are considered examples of material latent defects
  • underground storage tanks located on the property are a common example

BCFSA also says a seller is responsible for giving the agent accurate information about the home, and its list names the age of the home and the condition of the roof and the hot water heater.

Old wiring that an inspector can see in the panel is something a buyer can find. Wiring that was altered without a permit and closed behind a wall is hidden. Tell your agent about both. The first is priced, and the second has to be disclosed.

Should you fix it before you list?

Use numbers. For each item, get three:

  1. a written quote for the work
  2. a price range for the house as it is
  3. a price range for the house with the work done

Then choose one of three routes.

  • Fix it. This fits when the work is quick, the cost is clear, and it removes the insurer's question. Use permits, and keep the final inspection.
  • Document it. When the work is too costly, give buyers the quote and an inspection report. A buyer's insurer can then decide with facts, and may accept the house with a condition that the work is done by a date.
  • Price it. Set the price with the work in mind, and say so in the listing.

In our view, small electrical and roof repairs with a permit and an invoice are usually worth doing. Large projects rarely are for an owner who is leaving. Our guide to getting an older house ready to sell sorts repairs the same way.

What should be in the folder for buyers?

A buyer's insurance agent asks short, specific questions. Answer them before they are asked.

  • the year the house was built
  • the year of the roof, the furnace, the hot water tank, the electrical panel and any re-piping, with invoices
  • the type of wiring and the size of the electrical service
  • permits and final inspections for any work
  • a recent electrician's or roofer's report, if you have one
  • the oil tank papers, if a tank was ever there
  • a list of insurance claims you made, with the repair records

Give the folder to your agent before the listing goes live, and ask that it go to every buyer's agent who requests it.

What about your own insurance during the sale?

Your policy has conditions too. FCAC gives an example: if you are away for more than four days in a row when it is cold outside, your home insurance may not cover damage from frozen pipes. A house that stands empty while it is for sale needs the insurer to know.

Ask your insurer in writing:

  • whether the policy continues if nobody lives in the house
  • what it requires, such as regular visits or draining the water
  • whether showings and open houses change anything

This matters most for an estate or for an owner who has moved to care. Our guide to a move to a care home covers the empty house.

What if the buyer's insurer says no after the offer?

There are still choices, and they are quicker when the folder exists.

  1. Another insurer. Premiums and rules vary between companies. The buyer's broker can ask others.
  2. A repair before completion. The seller does the work, with a permit, and the completion date moves if needed.
  3. A repair after completion. An insurer may accept a house on the condition that the buyer fixes the item by a date. The price can reflect the cost.
  4. A holdback. Part of the sale money is held by a lawyer or notary until the work is done.

Your agent and the buyer's agent write the change into the contract, and your lawyer checks it.

Each insurer and each house is different. Confirm insurance questions with an insurance broker and contract wording with a lawyer before you sign.

Next step

Ask us for a free home value. A BC-licensed REALTOR® will email a price range based on recent sales of homes like yours, and we can go through the items a buyer's insurer may ask about. You do not have to sell with us. Our guide to selling after a life change covers other situations.

Questions we get

Frequently asked questions

Why does a buyer's home insurance matter to me as the seller?

A buyer who borrows needs insurance to complete. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says a home insurance policy on a mortgaged home usually includes a loss payee clause that makes the lender the beneficiary. A buyer who cannot get a policy cannot give the lender what it asks for, and the sale cannot complete.

What do home insurers look at?

The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says insurers may consider the type of residence, its characteristics such as the materials it is made of, its age, size and location, the distance to a fire hydrant or fire station, and the claims history, when they set the premium.

In our view the common ones are old wiring, an old roof, old plumbing, a heating system that burns oil or wood, a buried oil tank, and past water damage. Each insurer sets its own rules, so the answer for one house can differ between companies.

Disclose what a buyer could not find in a reasonable inspection. BC Financial Services Authority says new installations or renovations of electrical or gas systems completed without appropriate permits and inspections are examples of material latent defects, which must be disclosed before a contract.

Compare the cost with the price difference. Ask for a price range for the house as it is and as it would be after the work. Where the work is too costly, a written quote and an inspection report let a buyer and an insurer decide with facts.

Give the age of the roof, the wiring, the plumbing and the heating system, with invoices or permits for any replacement, and any inspection report you have. BC Financial Services Authority says a seller is responsible for accurate information about the home, including the condition of the roof.

Read your policy and ask in writing. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says home insurance may not cover some damage when you are away, such as frozen pipes after more than four days away in cold weather. An empty house for sale needs the insurer to know it is empty.

If the buyer's offer still has conditions, the buyer may decline to remove them. Another insurer may say yes, or may ask for a repair before or after completion. Your agent and the buyer's agent can agree on a repair, a price change or more time.

An insurer can ask about past claims, and the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada lists claims history among the factors insurers consider. Tell your agent about past claims and keep the repair records, so a buyer's insurer has the full account.

Buyers who pay without a mortgage have more freedom, because no lender asks for a policy. They still want insurance, and they still price in the repair. Clear records and a written quote keep more buyers in the group.

Sources

  1. Home insurance, Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  2. Material Latent Defects, BC Financial Services Authority (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  3. Listing Your Home, BC Financial Services Authority (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  4. Consumer Guide to Oil Tanks, BC Financial Services Authority (Accessed 2026-11-20)
Part of a guide

Selling after a life change

30 pieces that fit together. Read them in order, or jump to the one you need.

End of article

Found this useful? Share it.

A neighbour, a partner, a friend who's two FHSA contributions away, send it their way.

Save