A two-storey family house with cream walls and a brown roof, with a wide front lawn and tall green trees behind on a sunny day
Hub - Selling After a Life Change/
Save

Brothers and Sisters Inherited a House in BC and Disagree: Sell, Keep, or Buy Out?

A parent's house often passes to several children, and they do not always want the same thing. This guide explains who decides while the house is in the estate, what changes once the children are on title, how a buyout is priced, and what a court can order when nobody agrees.

Michael Goering, BC-licensed REALTOR®

Michael Goering·BC-licensed REALTOR®

A parent's house often passes to two or three children at once. One wants to sell, one wants to keep the house in the family, and one may already live there. This guide explains who decides at each stage, how a buyout works, and what a court can order when the family cannot agree.

It is general information about published rules. The estate's lawyer advises the executor, and each heir can get their own advice.

Who decides while the house is still in the estate?

After a death, the house does not go straight to the children. The Wills, Estates and Succession Act says land passes first to the personal representative. That is the executor named in the will, or an administrator appointed by the court when there is no will.

The Act then says the executor holds the land as a trustee for the people who are entitled to it. Two things follow from that.

  • The executor decides, following the will. If the will says "sell the house and divide the money", the executor sells. The heirs' agreement is not required.
  • The executor acts for all the heirs. A decision that favours one child over the others, such as free use of the house, has to be one the will allows.

BC Financial Services Authority (BCFSA), which regulates real estate agents, says an executor needs a grant of probate or letters of administration before they may have the legal authority to sign a listing agreement or a contract of sale. Our guide to probate when the estate has a house lists the steps.

So the first thing to read is the will. It usually gives one of three instructions:

What the will saysWhat happens to the house
Sell and divide the moneyThe executor sells. A child who wants the house can offer to buy it.
Give the house to the children in sharesThe executor transfers title to them, and they become co-owners.
Nothing specific about the houseThe house is part of what is left, and the executor deals with it under the will's general terms.

What changes once the children are on title?

If the house is transferred to the children, they own it together. BC's Property Law Act says that when land is transferred to two or more people, they are tenants in common unless the document shows a different intention. Each one owns a share and can leave it by will. Our guide to joint tenants and tenants in common explains both forms.

From then on, a sale needs everyone. BCFSA says that when a property has more than one registered owner, all of them are the sellers and must sign the listing contract, the contract that hires the agent to sell. One owner who refuses can stop a sale by agreement.

For that reason we suggest settling the house while it is still in the estate. One executor can sign a sale. Three co-owners have to agree on every step.

How does a buyout work?

When one child wants the house, the others receive money for their shares. Four steps make it work.

  1. A value everyone accepts. Order a written appraisal from a licensed appraiser, a professional who gives an opinion of value. Ask an agent for a price range from recent sales as a second check. If two numbers disagree, a second appraisal costs less than a dispute.
  2. The costs a sale would have had. A buyout has no commission. Decide in writing whether the price is reduced for that, and by how much. This is a matter for agreement between the heirs.
  3. The money. The buyer pays the others in cash or with a mortgage. A lender decides whether the buyer's income is enough.
  4. The paperwork. A lawyer or notary prepares the transfer. The Province's list of property transfer tax exemptions includes a transfer of a principal residence from the estate to a beneficiary who was a related individual of the person who died, when the home was that person's principal residence immediately before death. Ask the lawyer whether your transfer qualifies.

If the buyer is also the executor, take extra care. An executor is a trustee for every heir, and an executor who buys from the estate is on both sides of the price. Ask the estate's lawyer first, use an independent appraisal, and get every other heir's consent in writing.

What if one of you lives in the house?

A child who lived with the parent, or who moved in afterward, often wants time. The others want their share. Both wishes are fair, and the will may not cover it.

We suggest putting four points in writing early:

  • whether the person living there pays rent to the estate, and how much
  • who pays the tax, the insurance and the repairs
  • the date by which the house is listed or the buyout is completed
  • what happens if that date passes

Tell the home insurer who lives in the house. Ask the estate's lawyer what the executor may allow, because the executor answers to every heir for the result.

What can a court order when nobody agrees?

BC's Partition of Property Act covers co-owners who cannot agree. It says joint tenants and tenants in common can be compelled to divide or sell the land. Three of its rules matter for a family.

  • A request by half or more. When owners who hold one half or more of the property ask the court for a sale, the Act says the court must order the sale unless it sees good reason not to.
  • A request by any owner. The court may also order a sale at the request of any owner when a sale would benefit the owners more than dividing the land.
  • A buyout in place of a sale. One section of the Act says the court may not order a sale under it when the other owners undertake to purchase the share of the owner who asked for the sale. The court can then order a valuation of that share.

A court case costs money and takes time, and the legal bills reduce what the family shares. Go to a lawyer for this, and try the steps below first.

How do you keep the family out of court?

These are our suggestions.

  1. Read the will together. The will decides, whatever each person remembers a parent saying.
  2. Get one set of numbers. A written price range, sent to every heir on the same day, replaces three opinions with one.
  3. Work out each choice on paper. What each heir receives from a sale after costs, and what each receives from a buyout.
  4. Set a date. An open-ended wait costs everyone: tax, insurance and repairs continue.
  5. Use a neutral person. A mediator can help the family agree without a trial. Ask the estate's lawyer to suggest one.

The Act also sets a pace. An executor must not distribute the estate within 210 days after the grant is issued, unless a court orders it or the people the Act lists consent. That period is a good time to settle the house. Our guide to selling a parent's home covers the executor's other duties.

What about tax?

The Canada Revenue Agency says a person who dies is considered to have sold all their property just before death, at its fair market value on that date. That value becomes the starting point for whoever holds the house next. A rise in value after the death is reported when the house is sold.

For a family this means two things. Get a written value for the house as of the date of death. And ask an accountant before a buyout or a long delay, because a child who keeps the house and lives in it is taxed differently from children who hold it as an investment. Our post on capital gains and the principal residence explains the basics.

Each estate is different. Confirm legal questions with the estate's lawyer and tax questions with an accountant before you sign.

Next step

Ask us for a free home value. A BC-licensed REALTOR® will email a price range based on recent sales of homes like this one, and we send the same range to every heir on the same day. You do not have to sell with us. Our guide to selling after a life change covers estates, wills and other events.

Questions we get

Frequently asked questions

Who decides what happens to an inherited house in BC?

While the house is in the estate, the executor named in the will decides, following the will. The Wills, Estates and Succession Act says the executor holds the land as a trustee for the people entitled to it. Once title is transferred to the children, the owners decide together.

Can one sibling force the sale of an inherited house in BC?

A co-owner can ask the BC Supreme Court for a sale under the Partition of Property Act. When owners who hold one half or more of the property ask for a sale, the Act says the court must order it unless it sees good reason not to. A lawyer handles this application.

Yes, if the others agree to the price. An independent appraisal gives a value every heir can check. The buyer pays the others their shares, usually with a mortgage. The Partition of Property Act also deals with owners who undertake to purchase the share of the owner asking for a sale, and lets the court order a valuation of that share.

The will and the executor decide during the estate. An executor holds the house for all the heirs, so free use by one of them affects the others. We suggest a written agreement on rent, bills and a move-out date. Ask the estate's lawyer what the executor may allow.

While the house is in the estate, the executor signs the sale, following the will. After the house is transferred to the children, BC Financial Services Authority says every registered owner is a seller and must sign the listing contract. One owner who refuses then leaves the others with the court route.

Use a written appraisal from a licensed appraiser, dated close to the buyout. A price range from a real estate agent, based on recent sales, is a useful second check. The value on the date of death is a separate number, which the accountant needs for the tax returns.

The Province of BC lists an exemption for a transfer of a principal residence from the estate to a beneficiary who was a related individual of the person who died, when the home was that person's principal residence immediately before death. Other conditions apply, so ask the lawyer or notary who files the transfer.

The Canada Revenue Agency says a person who dies is considered to have sold all their property just before death, at its value on that date. A change in value between the death and the sale is reported after that. Ask an accountant how it is reported for your estate.

The Wills, Estates and Succession Act says an executor must not distribute the estate within 210 days after the grant is issued, unless the court orders it or the people the Act lists consent. The house can be sold in that time, and the money is held in the estate.

An executor holds the house as a trustee for every heir, so buying it from the estate puts the executor on both sides. Ask the estate's lawyer first. We suggest an independent appraisal and the written consent of every other heir before any price is set.

Sources

  1. Wills, Estates and Succession Act, SBC 2009, c. 13 (sections 155 and 162), Province of British Columbia, BC Laws (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  2. Partition of Property Act, RSBC 1996, c. 347 (sections 2, 6, 7 and 8), Province of British Columbia, BC Laws (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  3. Property Law Act, RSBC 1996, c. 377 (section 11), Province of British Columbia, BC Laws (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  4. Buying from an Estate, BC Financial Services Authority (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  5. Issues to Consider When Representing Spouses in the Sale of the Matrimonial Home (Report from Council, June 2014), BC Financial Services Authority (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  6. Property transfer tax exemption codes, Province of British Columbia (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  7. Capital gains: doing taxes for someone who died, Canada Revenue Agency (Accessed 2026-11-20)
  8. Changes to Ownership, Land Title and Survey Authority of British Columbia (Accessed 2026-11-20)
Free checklist

The Executor's House Checklist for BC

Two pages for an executor with a house to look after and sell: the first weeks, probate, what to settle before listing, the tax returns, and the waiting periods after the sale. Each line names the government source it comes from.

  • The first weeks: the will, the title, the insurer and the house bills
  • Probate: when a grant is needed, the notice period and the fee
  • Before listing and after the sale: who signs, the tax returns and the waiting periods
Michael Goering, BC-licensed REALTOR®

Put together by the FRIVE team with Michael Goering, BC-licensed REALTOR®.

Tell us where to send it, you'll get it right away.

No spamInstant PDFFree
Part of a guide

Selling after a life change

30 pieces that fit together. Read them in order, or jump to the one you need.

End of article

Found this useful? Share it.

A neighbour, a partner, a friend who's two FHSA contributions away, send it their way.

Save