A single-storey stucco house with a white tile roof, a white garage door, a wide concrete driveway and a tall palm tree on a green lawn, under a clear blue sky
Hub - Downsizing/
Save

Downsizing in BC? What to Do With Your Winter Home in Florida or Arizona

When you downsize in BC, the winter home in Florida or Arizona is part of the plan too. This guide explains the US tax held back when a Canadian sells, how to get it back, what to report in Canada, and what to check if you keep the home.

Khonia Shadbakht·Founder, BIMINIO Properties·Guest writer

My name is Khonia Shadbakht, and I am the founder of BIMINIO Properties. We buy houses in Florida and Arizona, and one of our two offices is in Vancouver. This guide is for BC owners who also own a winter home in a place like Tampa, Orlando or Phoenix, and who are planning a move to a smaller home here. Keep the winter home, sell it, or rent it out?

This guide explains what happens when a Canadian sells a US home, how to get back the money held back at closing, what to report in Canada, and what to check if you keep the home. It is general information about rules that the US and Canadian tax offices publish. Each person's case is different, so take your own numbers to an accountant who works on both sides of the border before you sign anything.

Why the winter home belongs in your downsizing plan

Downsizing in BC starts with one house: what it sells for, where you go next, and what you keep. A second home in the US adds a second country's rules to the same plan. Selling it brings a US tax filing and a Canadian one. Keeping it brings a yearly cost and, in the long run, a question about US estate tax.

I suggest deciding about both homes together. The two sales can fall in the same tax year, and in Canada only one home per family unit can be named as your principal residence for each year. Which home you name for which years can change the tax on both sales.

Option 1: sell the winter home

The buyer holds back part of the price

When a person who is not a US resident sells US real estate, a US law called FIRPTA applies. The IRS says the rate of withholding is generally 15% of the amount realized, which for a normal sale is the price. In most cases the buyer is the one who holds back that amount at closing and sends it to the IRS.

That 15% is a payment toward your US tax. The final tax is worked out on your US return.

Say you sell your winter home for US$400,000 (a made-up number). At closing, the buyer holds back 15%, which is US$60,000, and sends it to the IRS. You receive the rest of the price, less your closing costs. Next spring you file your US return. If the return shows your US tax on the sale is US$20,000, the IRS refunds the other US$40,000. If you never file, that money stays with the IRS.

These are federal US rules, so they are the same in Florida and in Arizona. The state you sell in changes other things, such as Florida's tax on the deed and how closing is done, and your closing agent in that state can tell you what applies. If your gain is small, most of it comes back to you after you file.

There is one common exception. The IRS lists a residence exception: nothing is held back when the buyer is an individual, the price is not more than $300,000, and the buyer or a family member plans to live in the home for at least half of the days it is used in each of the first two years after the sale. Whether a sale qualifies depends on the buyer, so ask your closing agent early.

Getting the money back

You get the held-back money back through a US income tax return. The IRS says the seller must file a US income tax return for the sale. After the buyer sends the withholding, the IRS stamps a copy of Form 8288-A and mails it to the seller. You attach that stamped copy to your return to get credit for the tax withheld.

The stamped copy needs your US tax number. If you have none, the IRS says you can apply for an ITIN, a US tax number for people who cannot get a Social Security number, using Form W-7. Without a number on the forms, the IRS does not send the stamped copy, and you must prove the withholding another way, for example with your closing papers. I suggest that every Canadian seller sorts out the tax number before closing day.

Asking for less to be held back

If 15% of the price is more than the tax you will owe, you can ask the IRS for a withholding certificate before the sale. The IRS may allow a smaller amount when the full withholding would be more than your maximum tax on the sale. It says it generally acts within 90 days of a complete application. You must tell the buyer in writing on the day of the transfer or the day before. An application needs the tax numbers of everyone in the sale, which is one more reason to start early.

The Florida deed tax

Florida charges a tax on the deed. The Florida Department of Revenue says the documentary stamp tax rate is 70 cents on each $100 of the price. Miami-Dade County has its own rate of 60 cents on each $100. Your purchase contract says which side pays it, so read that line before you sign.

Reporting the sale in Canada

As a resident of Canada you report the sale on your Canadian return as well. To keep you from paying tax twice on the same gain, the CRA lets a Canadian resident claim a foreign tax credit for income tax paid to another country on income also reported in Canada. The federal part is worked out on Form T2209. For BC, Form T2036 works out the provincial part.

The numbers on your Canadian return are in Canadian dollars. The CRA's folio on reporting currency says amounts are converted at the rate for the day on which each amount arises, and that this is the rate the Bank of Canada quotes for that day. So the price you paid is converted at the rate on the day you bought, and the price you sold for at the rate on the day you sold. If the US dollar rose against the Canadian dollar while you owned the home, your gain in Canadian dollars can be larger than your gain in US dollars. Keep your closing papers from both dates.

Can the winter home be your principal residence?

It can, depending on the facts. The CRA's principal residence folio says a property outside Canada can qualify as a principal residence. The same folio says only one property per family unit can be designated for each year after 1981. If you are selling your BC house and your US house close together, the two compete for the same years. Decide which home gets which years with your accountant, with the numbers for both sales in front of you.

Option 2: keep the winter home

Some owners keep the US house and sell only in BC. Check these three things first.

Form T1135

The CRA uses Form T1135 to collect information on property held outside Canada. Its questions and answers say vacation property you use primarily as a personal residence is excluded. Once you rent the home out for profit for most of the year, it counts. The form is required when the total cost of your foreign property is more than $100,000 at any time in the year, and the test uses cost, which is what you paid.

US estate tax

US real estate counts as a US asset for US estate tax. The IRS says the executor of a nonresident's estate must file Form 706-NA when the value of the person's US assets at death is more than $60,000. The IRS also says tax treaties can change which assets count. Canada and the US have a treaty, and how it applies depends on your whole estate. If you plan to keep the house into your later years, ask a cross-border advisor to look at this now, while you can still change the plan.

Renting it out

Renting the home brings its own US and Canadian rules for rental income, and it can change your Form T1135 answer. If you are thinking of renting, get advice on that before the first tenant moves in.

How a direct sale works, and when it fits

You can sell a US home the usual way, with a listing agent, or you can sell it directly to a buyer like BIMINIO.

We buy houses as they are, so the seller does not repair, clean or stage anything. We send a written cash offer within 24 hours of getting the details we need, and the seller picks a closing date between 7 and 35 days out. The seller pays no commission to us. FIRPTA applies to any buyer, us included, so the 15% rule above is the same when you sell to us.

A direct sale fits some owners better than others. It suits an owner in BC who cannot fly down for repairs and showings, a house that needs work, or a seller who wants a fixed date. A house in top condition, with an owner who has time and can manage a listing from a distance, may sell for more on the open market. Ask for both numbers and compare what you keep after costs.

Questions to ask before you accept any offer

Whichever way you sell, a few questions protect you. Ask the closing agent who will hold back the 15% and when you will receive the paperwork that shows it was sent to the IRS. Ask what you will pay at closing in total, including the deed tax and any fees. Ask whether you can sign the closing papers from BC, or whether you need to be there in person. And ask for the offer in writing, with the closing date, before you decide.

A short checklist before you decide

  1. Find your closing papers from the purchase and every receipt for work done on the home.
  2. Get a US tax number if you do not have one.
  3. Ask a cross-border accountant to estimate your US tax on the sale, and whether a withholding certificate makes sense.
  4. Plan the sales of your BC house and your US house together, including which one is named your principal residence for which years.
  5. If you keep the US home, ask about US estate tax and Form T1135.
  6. Read the contract line that says who pays the deed tax and closing costs.

FRIVE's downsizing checklist covers the BC side of the move, and its guide to capital gains and the principal residence explains how the exemption works on your BC home.

This guide summarizes rules the IRS, the CRA and the Florida Department of Revenue publish. It is general information, and tax law in both countries changes. Confirm every number with your own accountant or lawyer before you act.

Next step

Most downsizers start with the BC house. Ask FRIVE for a free home value, and a BC-licensed REALTOR® will email you a price range based on recent sales of homes like yours. The downsizing calculator shows what you keep after selling, and the downsizing page puts the whole move in order.

Questions we get

Frequently asked questions

Do I pay US tax when I sell my Florida or Arizona home as a Canadian?

The sale is reported to the US. The IRS says a foreign seller of US real estate must file a US income tax return for the year of the sale. The tax owed depends on your gain. In most sales the buyer also holds back part of the price at closing and sends it to the IRS as a payment toward that tax.

How much of the price is held back when a Canadian sells a US home?

Under a US law called FIRPTA, the IRS says the rate of withholding is generally 15% of the amount realized, which for most sales is the price. In most cases the buyer is the one who holds it back and sends it to the IRS. The amount held back is a payment toward your US tax, and any extra comes back after you file.

The IRS lists a residence exception. Nothing is held back when the buyer is an individual, the price is not more than $300,000, and the buyer or a family member plans to live in the home for at least half of the days it is used in each of the first two years. Your closing agent confirms whether the exception applies.

File a US income tax return for the year of the sale. The IRS stamps a copy of Form 8288-A and sends it to the seller, and you attach that stamped copy to your return to get credit for the tax withheld. If more was held back than you owe, the rest is refunded.

Yes. You can apply to the IRS for a withholding certificate when the amount held back would be more than your maximum tax on the sale. The IRS says it generally acts within 90 days of a complete application. You must tell the buyer in writing on the day of the transfer or the day before.

It helps. The IRS says a withholding certificate application needs the tax numbers of everyone in the sale. A seller with no number can apply for an ITIN, a US tax number for people who cannot get a Social Security number, by attaching the completed certificate application to Form W-7. Start early, because the number is needed for the stamped form.

Yes, if you live in Canada. The CRA lets a Canadian resident claim a foreign tax credit on Form T2209 for income tax paid to another country on income reported in Canada. Form T2036 does the same for the provincial part in BC. An accountant who works on both sides of the border can set out the numbers.

The CRA's folio on reporting currency says amounts are converted at the rate for the day on which each amount arises, and that the rate is the one quoted by the Bank of Canada on that day. In practice the purchase is converted at the rate on the day you bought, and the sale at the rate on the day you sold.

It can, depending on the facts. The CRA's principal residence folio says a property outside Canada can qualify. Only one property per family unit can be designated for each year, so if you also sell your BC house, the two compete for the same years. Choose with your accountant before you file.

Not while you use it mainly as your own. The CRA says vacation property used primarily as a personal residence is excluded from Form T1135. A property rented out for profit for most of the year is reported once the total cost of your foreign property passes $100,000 at any time in the year.

US real estate counts as a US asset for US estate tax. The IRS says the executor must file Form 706-NA when the value of a nonresident's US assets at death is more than $60,000. A tax treaty can change the result, so a cross-border advisor should review it before you decide to keep the home.

Yes, on the deed. The Florida Department of Revenue says the documentary stamp tax rate is 70 cents on each $100 of the price. Miami-Dade County has its own rate of 60 cents on each $100. Your purchase contract says which side pays it.

Sources

  1. FIRPTA withholding, Internal Revenue Service (Last reviewed 2026-07-21, accessed 2026-11-14)
  2. Exceptions from FIRPTA withholding, Internal Revenue Service (Last reviewed 2026-07-15, accessed 2026-11-14)
  3. Withholding certificates, Internal Revenue Service (Last reviewed 2026-07-23, accessed 2026-11-14)
  4. Reporting and paying tax on U.S. real property interests, Internal Revenue Service (Last reviewed 2026-07-23, accessed 2026-11-14)
  5. Some nonresidents with U.S. assets must file estate tax returns, Internal Revenue Service (Last reviewed 2026-06-27, accessed 2026-11-14)
  6. Line 40500, Federal foreign tax credit, Canada Revenue Agency (Modified 2026-08-14, accessed 2026-11-14)
  7. Questions and answers about Form T1135, Canada Revenue Agency (Modified 2026-10-19, accessed 2026-11-14)
  8. Income Tax Folio S5-F4-C1, Income Tax Reporting Currency, Canada Revenue Agency (Updated 2024-06-27, accessed 2026-11-14)
  9. Income Tax Folio S1-F3-C2, Principal Residence, Canada Revenue Agency (Accessed 2026-11-14)
  10. Documentary stamp tax, Florida Department of Revenue (Accessed 2026-11-14)
Free guide

The Fraser Valley Downsizing Guide

Eight pages on selling the family house and buying a smaller home: the steps in order, prices by city, the costs of selling and buying, the tax rules, and what to read before you buy in a strata. Written for owners who have not sold a home in a long time.

  • The move in eight steps, from the first price check to the paperwork after you move
  • Benchmark prices for houses, townhouses and condos in six Fraser Valley cities
  • The costs of selling and buying, and the tax rules on the sale of your home
Michael Goering, BC-licensed REALTOR®

Put together by the FRIVE team with Michael Goering, BC-licensed REALTOR®.

Tell us where to send it, you'll get it right away.

No spamInstant PDFFree
Part of a guide

Downsizing in the Fraser Valley

20 pieces that fit together. Read them in order, or jump to the one you need.

End of article

Found this useful? Share it.

A neighbour, a partner, a friend who's two FHSA contributions away, send it their way.

Save